TRADITIONAL INGREDIENTS
we use the same ingredients AUTHENTIC bagel-makers have been using for decades
Authentic Bagels
Each bagel is carefully rolled
by hand using a method PASSED DOWN GENERATIONS dating back to 1906
inventive sandwiches
our sandwiches are loaded
with unique flavor combinations & fresh ingredients
the Menu
Gotham Bagels are the best in the midwest, period.
Gotham Bagels was started in 2006 by a New Yorker with a dream - a dream of bringing authentic, delicious, New York-Style bagels to the Midwest!
Need More than a Dozen Bagels?
Cater with Gotham Bagels! We’ve got platters for every occasion, just make sure you don’t forget the cream cheese!
In loving memory of
Kenneth Scharf (1956-2021)
Pictured here with fellow Gotham Bagels co-founder Joe Gaglio.
