Fun and Creative Ways to Customize Your Gotham Bagel

At Gotham Bagels, we believe that creativity in the kitchen is just as important as tradition. While we’re known for our signature bagel creations, we want to remind you that the real magic happens when you make your bagel your own. Whether you're a regular or a first-time visitor, there are endless ways to mix and match our ingredients to create a bagel experience that's uniquely yours. Let’s dive into some fun and creative ways to customize your Gotham Bagel!

1. Start with a Bagel Base

The first step in your customization journey is choosing the perfect bagel base. From the classic Plain and Sesame to the more adventurous Asiago and Pumpernickel, each bagel has its own unique flavor profile. If you're feeling extra bold, why not try a Cinnamon Raisin bagel with a savory filling? Or go for an Egg Everything bagel to really kick things up a notch. The possibilities are endless!

2. Pick Your Perfect Cream Cheese

Once you’ve picked your bagel, it’s time to add the cream cheese. If you're a purist, go for the classic Plain or Scallion cream cheese. For something a little more unique, try our Vegan Scallion for a dairy-free option, or give the Lox cream cheese a go for a delightful twist on the classic bagel and lox combination. Want something sweet? The Strawberry cream cheese is perfect for those who like to balance savory with a touch of sweetness.

3. Upgrade Your Sandwich Creations

We’re proud of our signature sandwiches, but did you know you can customize them to suit your tastes? Swap the Spicy Sausage in the Spicy Sausage, Egg & Cheddar for our Thick-Cut Bacon or even Turkey Bacon for a lighter touch. Prefer something lighter? Try swapping in Arugula for the usual lettuce or add some Avocado for that creamy, dreamy texture.

Feel like getting fancy? Why not try the Brighton Beach sandwich (premium Atlantic cold-smoked salmon with all the fresh fixings) and swap out the Arugula for Cucumber for an extra refreshing crunch? Or, make the Traditional Tuna Fish even better with a dash of Lemon or Capers for that extra zing.

4. Go Signature,

Go Bold If you’re in the mood for something special, Gotham Bagels has a selection of signature sandwiches that are bound to surprise and delight. Try the OMFG with its crispy Nashville fried chicken and thick-cut bacon. If you're not a fan of spicy aioli, feel free to substitute with your favorite sauce or skip it altogether!

The Pastrami & Egg and The Williamsburg are also great options to mix up your bagel routine. Add a bit of NY Strong Mustard to your Pastrami & Egg or switch up the Coleslaw in The Williamsburg for a tangy Sauerkraut twist. The best part? You get to make it just the way you like it.

5. Seasonal Specials

Let Your Taste Buds Explore At Gotham Bagels, we love to keep things fresh with seasonal specials. Whether it's a new cream cheese flavor or a limited-time bagel creation, there’s always something new to try. Ask about our current seasonal specials and get ready to experience a whole new level of bagel creativity. Who knows? You might discover a new favorite!

6. Customize Your Sides and Drinks

Don't forget about your sides! Pair your bagel creation with some Potato Latkes, a refreshing Iced Coffee from Passion House, or a comforting cup of Hot Coffee. Our sides and drinks are just as customizable as our bagels, so feel free to mix and match to complete your Gotham Bagel experience.

So next time you’re in the mood for a bagel, remember: your ideal creation is just a customization away. Whether you're keeping it classic or going bold, the choice is yours, and we can't wait to see what delicious creations you come up with.