Best Bagels In Madison, WI!

Opened by Joey Bagels himself, this location has become a mainstay in the Madison community. Cranking out authentic NY bagels, and even some other NY style goodies, our Madison location is the real deal! Gotham has been serving handmade New York style bagels for more than twenty years! We make our bagels the traditional way – mixing the ingredients in house, rolling by hand, kettle-boiling, and baking in a rotating deck oven. We offer gourmet sandwich creations, house-smoked white fish, thin sliced pastrami, and premium smoked salmon. Enjoy the finest pickles in the country, and traditionally mixed tuna fish salad.

Catering

madison Merch

contact us