The Menu
Madison, WI Menu
Real New York bagels. Rolled by hand in the Midwest. Kettle-boiled and baked fresh every morning.
Prices match our online ordering as of October 8, 2026, before tax. For today's availability, order online.
Signatures
-
Bacon, Egg, & Cheddar $9.75
Fried egg, aged cheddar, & thick cut bacon.
Dietary & allergen info: Bacon, Egg, & Cheddar Order this: Bacon, Egg, & Cheddar -
O.M.F.G. $13.75
Fried egg, aged cheddar, Nashville fried chicken, thick cut bacon, & Calabrian chili aioli.
Dietary & allergen info: O.M.F.G. Order this: O.M.F.G. -
The Original "V" $11.25
The great vegan! Vegan scallion cream cheese, poblano salad, tomato, arugula, & avocado. Includes Gotham's Finest Pickle.
Dietary & allergen info: The Original "V" Order this: The Original "V" -
Bronx Bomber $11.25
Piled high Calabrese salami, La Quercia prosciutto, mortadella, provolone, greens, tomato, Chicago Johnny's hot giardiniera.
Dietary & allergen info: Bronx Bomber Order this: Bronx Bomber
Bagels, Lox, & More
- Single Bagel $2.25 Loose bagels do not come sliced. Dietary & allergen info: Single Bagel
- Dozen Bagels $23 Choose 13 bagels. We suggest three 8oz containers of cream cheese per dozen. Dietary & allergen info: Dozen Bagels
- 8oz Container of Cream Cheese $8 8oz house whipped cream cheese or 8oz whipped butter. Dietary & allergen info: 8oz Container of Cream Cheese
- Fresh Fruit Cup $6 10 oz. Pineapple, blueberries, and grapes. Dietary & allergen info: Fresh Fruit Cup
- Thinly Sliced Lox by the Half Pound or Pound $18.75 With capers and red onion. Half pound shown; a pound is +$16.00. Dietary & allergen info: Thinly Sliced Lox by the Half Pound or Pound
- Traditional Matzo Ball Soup $7 Served hot. Dietary & allergen info: Traditional Matzo Ball Soup
- Spicy Chicken Tortilla Soup $6 Topped with cotija cheese. Ask for no cheese to make it dairy free. Dietary & allergen info: Spicy Chicken Tortilla Soup
- Big City Coffee Cake $6.25 Dietary & allergen info: Big City Coffee Cake
- Curried Hummus with Za'atar $8 8 oz. Dietary & allergen info: Curried Hummus with Za'atar
- Hot Smoked Salmon $18 Dietary & allergen info: Hot Smoked Salmon
- Freezer Bag $0.35 Single bag. Dietary & allergen info: Freezer Bag
- Freezer Bags (5 pack) $2.25 Eco-friendly 5-pack of freezer bags. Bio-based film derived from sugar cane. Each bag holds 6 NY bagels. Dietary & allergen info: Freezer Bags (5 pack)
- Gotham Frozen Bagels $8 Better than others' fresh! 6 pack assorted. Please do not request flavors on frozen bagels; flavors fluctuate daily. Dietary & allergen info: Gotham Frozen Bagels
- Babka for One $7 Dietary & allergen info: Babka for One
- Babka Loaf $18 24 oz. Certified Kosher and parve. Dietary & allergen info: Babka Loaf
- Traditional Rugelach $13 14 oz bag. Certified Kosher and parve. Dietary & allergen info: Traditional Rugelach
- Traditional Hamantaschen $10.25 12 oz box. Dietary & allergen info: Traditional Hamantaschen
- Black and White Cookie $3 3.5 oz. Individually wrapped. Dietary & allergen info: Black and White Cookie
- Gluten-Free Chocolate Chip Cookie $1.25 Dietary & allergen info: Gluten-Free Chocolate Chip Cookie
- Big Chocolate Chip Cookie $3 Dietary & allergen info: Big Chocolate Chip Cookie
- Flyte Farm Tomato $3 Grown in Coloma, Wisconsin. Dietary & allergen info: Flyte Farm Tomato
Hand-Rolled Bagel Flavors
- Plain
- Sesame
- Everything
- Poppy
- Cinnamon Raisin
- Onion
- Garlic
- Salt
- Honey Whole Wheat
- Egg
- Blueberry
- Super Egg Everything +$0.50
- Pumpernickel +$0.50
- Bialy +$0.50
- Calabrian Chili, Mozzarella & Parmigiano +$1.50
Cream Cheese Flavors (8oz)
- Plain
- Scallion
- Veggie
- Plain Tofutti
- Scallion Tofutti
- Honey Tart Cherry
- Jalapeño Garlic
- Caper
- Whipped Butter
- Smoked Salmon +$0.50
- Whipped Feta, Rosemary & Cracked Black Pepper +$0.50
- Blueberry (Farmer's Market) +$0.50
- Artichoke Spinach Parmesan +$1.00
Sandwiches
- Bagel & Cream Cheese $5.25 Dietary & allergen info: Bagel & Cream Cheese
- Bacon, Egg, & Cheddar $9.75 Fried egg, aged cheddar, & thick cut bacon. Dietary & allergen info: Bacon, Egg, & Cheddar
- Lox & Cream Cheese $10.75 Lox and your choice of cream cheese. Dietary & allergen info: Lox & Cream Cheese
- Spicy Italian Sausage, Egg, & Cheddar $11.75 Over-easy egg, aged cheddar, Gotham-made spicy Italian sausage. Dietary & allergen info: Spicy Italian Sausage, Egg, & Cheddar
- Brighton Beach $14.75 Lox, caper cream cheese, greens, tomato, red onion, capers. Dietary & allergen info: Brighton Beach
- O.M.F.G. $13.75 Fried egg, aged cheddar, Nashville fried chicken, thick cut bacon, & Calabrian chili aioli. Dietary & allergen info: O.M.F.G.
- The Rocky's Deli $13.75 The return of a Gotham original: fried egg, thick cut bacon, aged cheddar, potato latke, spicy ketchup. Dietary & allergen info: The Rocky's Deli
- Egg & Cheddar $9 Dietary & allergen info: Egg & Cheddar
- Pastrami & Egg (Early Willy) $10.75 Piled high over an over-easy egg. Dietary & allergen info: Pastrami & Egg (Early Willy)
- Smoked Heritage Ham, Egg, & Gouda $10.75 Fried egg, locally smoked ham, aged Gouda. Dietary & allergen info: Smoked Heritage Ham, Egg, & Gouda
- The Yellow C.A.B. $11 Cheddar, avocado, bacon, arugula, tomato & mayo. Dietary & allergen info: The Yellow C.A.B.
- Super Tuscan $12.25 Fried egg, fresh mozzarella, heirloom tomato, Vitruvian greens, and pesto. Dietary & allergen info: Super Tuscan
- Bronx Bomber $11.25 Piled high Calabrese salami, La Quercia prosciutto, mortadella, provolone, greens, tomato, Chicago Johnny's hot giardiniera. Dietary & allergen info: Bronx Bomber
- Williamsburg Hot Pastrami $13 Piled high hot pastrami with NY strong mustard. Served with pickle and NY deli coleslaw. Dietary & allergen info: Williamsburg Hot Pastrami
- Massapequa $12.25 Grilled herbed chicken breast, roasted red peppers, fontina, greens and pesto. Dietary & allergen info: Massapequa
- Woodlawn Corned Beef $13 Piled high corned beef & NY strong mustard. Make it a Reuben +$2.75. Dietary & allergen info: Woodlawn Corned Beef
- The Original "V" $11.25 The great vegan! Vegan scallion cream cheese, poblano salad, tomato, arugula, & avocado. Includes Gotham's Finest Pickle. Dietary & allergen info: The Original "V"
- The Amagansett $11.25 House-made whitefish salad, Vitruvian baby greens, cucumber, hot house tomato, red onion. Dietary & allergen info: The Amagansett
- Port Washington $13.25 Hot smoked salmon salad (red onion, celery, parsley, salt & pepper), avocado mash, tomato, baby greens, citrus vinaigrette. Dietary & allergen info: Port Washington
- Long Island $11.25 Smoked turkey breast, fontina, greens, tomato, mayo. Dietary & allergen info: Long Island
- NY Deli Chicken Salad $9.75 Petite greens, heirloom tomatoes. Dietary & allergen info: NY Deli Chicken Salad
- Traditional Tuna Salad Sandwich $9.75 Arugula, tomato. Dietary & allergen info: Traditional Tuna Salad Sandwich
- Hall of Fame Breakfast Featured $16.50 Wagyu skirt steak, scrambled egg, aged Wisconsin cheddar, Flyte Farm tomato, Vitruvian Farm greens, Kewpie mayo. Dietary & allergen info: Hall of Fame Breakfast
Deli & Bulk
- Bowtie Pesto Pasta Salad $4.75 8 oz. Dietary & allergen info: Bowtie Pesto Pasta Salad
- Traditional Tuna Salad $5.75 Dietary & allergen info: Traditional Tuna Salad
- Gotham Chicken Salad $5.75 Dietary & allergen info: Gotham Chicken Salad
- Gotham Whitefish Salad $10.50 8 oz. Dietary & allergen info: Gotham Whitefish Salad
- Port Washington Salmon Salad $8 Dietary & allergen info: Port Washington Salmon Salad
- Pastrami by the Pound $20.50 Sold by the pound. Comes with NY strong mustard. Dietary & allergen info: Pastrami by the Pound
- Gotham Pickles $6.50 Dietary & allergen info: Gotham Pickles
- NY Deli Coleslaw $3.25 Dietary & allergen info: NY Deli Coleslaw
- Vitruvian Farms Baby Greens Mix $5.50 5 oz. Locally grown produce, McFarland, Wisconsin. Dietary & allergen info: Vitruvian Farms Baby Greens Mix
- 30-Month-Old Parmigiano-Reggiano $25 Per pound. The one and only. Dietary & allergen info: 30-Month-Old Parmigiano-Reggiano
Extras
- Bag of Bagel Chips $4 Made in house. Dietary & allergen info: Bag of Bagel Chips
- Joe Chips $2.25 Retro potato chips. Dietary & allergen info: Joe Chips
- Coffee Refill $0.50 Dietary & allergen info: Coffee Refill
- 4 oz Fruit Cup $2.50 Dietary & allergen info: 4 oz Fruit Cup
- 12 oz Fruit Cup $6 Dietary & allergen info: 12 oz Fruit Cup
Beverages
JBC Coffee Roasters, roasted right here in Madison: a six-time Good Food Award winner that Forbes named one of the 12 best coffee roasters in the U.S. Served in iconic NYC coffee cups.
- Strong Coffee $2.75 Your choice of light or dark roast, served hot in iconic NYC coffee cups. Dietary & allergen info: Strong Coffee
- Iced Coffee $3.25 Dietary & allergen info: Iced Coffee
- Fresh Squeezed Juice $5.50 Dietary & allergen info: Fresh Squeezed Juice
- Coca-Cola Products $1.25 Dietary & allergen info: Coca-Cola Products
- Dr. Brown's Soda $1.75 Dietary & allergen info: Dr. Brown's Soda
- Aqua Panna Water $2.75 Dietary & allergen info: Aqua Panna Water
- San Pellegrino Sparkling Mineral Water $3 Dietary & allergen info: San Pellegrino Sparkling Mineral Water
- Nicolet Spring Water $2 Dietary & allergen info: Nicolet Spring Water
- Fiji Bottled Water $5 1 liter bottle. Dietary & allergen info: Fiji Bottled Water
- Waiakea Water $5 1 liter Hawaiian volcanic water. Dietary & allergen info: Waiakea Water
- Powerade $2.75 Dietary & allergen info: Powerade
- San Pellegrino Fruit Soda $3 Dietary & allergen info: San Pellegrino Fruit Soda
- Joe Tea $3.50 Dietary & allergen info: Joe Tea
- Summer Lemonade $3.50 Joe's Lemonade, 16 oz can made with cane sugar. Dietary & allergen info: Summer Lemonade
- Mountain Valley Spring Water $6 Dietary & allergen info: Mountain Valley Spring Water
- Topo Chico $2.75 Sparkling water with real fruit juice. Dietary & allergen info: Topo Chico
Catering
Every platter comes with a dozen (13) bagels and serves 13. Please order at least one day in advance.
- Riverside Park Platter $112 NY Dozen®, 1 lb lox, 2-8oz spreads, baby greens, tomato, cucumber, Big City pickles, red onion, and capers. Dietary & allergen info: Riverside Park Platter
- Long Island Platter $105 NY Dozen®, 1 lb traditional tuna salad, 1 lb traditional chicken salad, 1 lb sliced turkey, tomatoes, baby greens, red onion, Big City pickles and Gotham Finest coleslaw. Dietary & allergen info: Long Island Platter
- Brighton Beach Platter $139 NY Dozen®, 1 lb lox, 8 oz hot smoked salmon, 8 oz smoked whitefish salad, 2-8oz spreads, baby greens, red onion, tomatoes, cucumber, Big City pickles. Dietary & allergen info: Brighton Beach Platter
- Williamsburg Platter $120 NY Dozen®, 1 lb smoked heritage ham, 1 lb pastrami, 1 lb corned beef, 8 oz deli coleslaw, (2) 4 oz Gotham deli mustard, & Big City pickles. Dietary & allergen info: Williamsburg Platter
- Big City Fruit Platter $45 Pineapple, grapes, blueberries, cantaloupe. Dietary & allergen info: Big City Fruit Platter
- Joe to Go Coffee Service $49 JBC coffee service for 12 people. Includes cups, cream, and sugar. Dietary & allergen info: Joe to Go Coffee Service
Grocery
- Cav. Giuseppe Cocco - Farfalle $5.75 17.6 oz. Product of Italy. Dietary & allergen info: Cav. Giuseppe Cocco - Farfalle
- Cav. Giuseppe Cocco - Penne $5.75 Dietary & allergen info: Cav. Giuseppe Cocco - Penne
- Garofalo - Orzo $4 Dietary & allergen info: Garofalo - Orzo
- Garofalo - Linguine $4 Dietary & allergen info: Garofalo - Linguine
- Mafaldine (Imported Sicilian Pasta) $8.94 Joey Bagels preferred dry pasta. Dietary & allergen info: Mafaldine (Imported Sicilian Pasta)
- Everything Spice $6 12 oz container. Dietary & allergen info: Everything Spice
- Hot Giardiniera $8.75 Olive oil based, bold and smoky flavor. 16 oz. Dietary & allergen info: Hot Giardiniera
- JBC Black Earth Coffee, Whole Bean $14 12 oz whole bean coffee. Notes of praline, vanilla, dark chocolate. Dietary & allergen info: JBC Black Earth Coffee, Whole Bean
- Sicilian Oregano on Branches $8 25g, imported. Dietary & allergen info: Sicilian Oregano on Branches
- St. Elmo Steak House Shrimp Cocktail Sauce $9.95 Very spicy, 12 oz. Dietary & allergen info: St. Elmo Steak House Shrimp Cocktail Sauce
- Ortiz Anchovy $8 Dietary & allergen info: Ortiz Anchovy
- Ortiz Sardine $8 Sardines in olive oil, 140g. Dietary & allergen info: Ortiz Sardine
*Consuming raw or undercooked meats, poultry, seafood, shellfish, or eggs may increase your risk of food borne illness. Menu items may contain or come into contact with wheat, eggs, peanuts, tree nuts, and milk. Every item has a "Dietary & allergen info" link, and the full list is on our allergen & dietary information page.
Mouth Watering Yet?
Get more details about our bagels or find your nearest location below for current availability and menu details.