Madison, WI catering

Bagel catering in Madison

Platters built on a New York Dozen, deli salads, lox and JBC coffee for Capitol offices, UW departments, law firms and family tables, from our original shop a block off Capitol Square. Schedule online up to 90 days ahead.

Order Madison catering See the platters

Riverside Park: a NY Dozen®, 1 lb lox and two spreads. Serves 13.

Where we cater from

Madison, WI (Capitol Square), 112 E Mifflin St., Madison, WI 53703. Madison catering covers Capitol offices, UW departments, law firms and conferences at Monona Terrace. Every platter comes with a New York Dozen, and JBC coffee service serves 12. Schedule online up to 90 days ahead, and for big orders give us at least a day.

Shop hours: Tue–Sat 8 am – 2 pm; Sun 8 am till we run out! (Usually noon). Closed Mondays.

Delivery and pickup

Delivery is $9 within the City of Madison and $15 to Middleton or Sun Prairie. Anywhere else, call or email us. You can schedule orders online up to 90 days ahead.

What's on the Madison catering menu

Every platter comes with a dozen (13) bagels and serves 13 people, with baby greens, tomato, red onion, Big City pickles and coleslaw. Madison has its own menu, separate from the Chicago shops.

Riverside Park 13 bagels, 1 lb lox, two 8 oz spreads · serves 13 · $112
Long Island 13 bagels, 1 lb each tuna salad, chicken salad and turkey · serves 13 · $105
Brighton Beach 13 bagels, 1 lb lox, 8 oz hot smoked salmon, 8 oz whitefish salad, two 8 oz spreads · serves 13 · $139
Williamsburg 13 bagels, 1 lb each ham, pastrami and corned beef · serves 13 · $120
One Dozen® 13 unsliced bagels · $23
Cream Cheese One 8 oz container · $8
Big City Fruit Platter Pineapple, grapes, blueberries, cantaloupe · $45
Coffee Service JBC coffee, cups, cream and sugar · serves 12 · $49

Full Madison catering menu How much should I order? Office catering

Everything the Madison shop makes for catering, with prices as published on our online ordering menu. Email madison@gothambagels.com with any specific questions.

A La Carte

Hand Rolled Bagels $2.25

Bagels come unsliced. Plain, Sesame, Everything, Poppy, Cinnamon Raisin, Onion, Garlic, Salt, Honey Whole Wheat, Egg, Blueberry, The Super Egg Everything, Pumpernickel, Bialy, Calabrian Chili with Mozzarella & Parmigiano
- Add $0.50 for Pumpernickel
- Add $0.50 for The Super Egg Everything
- Add $0.50 for Bialy
- Add $1.50 for Calabrian Chili with Mozzarella & Parmigiano
One Dozen® $23

13 unsliced bagels in a brown bag. We suggest three 8oz containers of cream cheese per dozen.
Cream Cheese $8

All flavors, 8oz containers, Plain, Scallion, Veggie, Caper, Plain Tofutti, Scallion Tofutti, Honey Tart Cherry, Jalapeno Garlic, or Whipped Butter
Specialty Cream Cheese $8.50

8oz containers, Smoked Salmon, Whipped Feta Rosemary and Cracked Black Pepper, Blueberry (seasonal)
- Artichoke Spinach Parmesan $9
Coffee Service $49

JBC coffee, cups, cream and sugar for 12

Big City Value Platters

Riverside Park $112

NY Dozen®, 1 lb lox, 2-8oz spreads, Baby Greens, Tomato, Cucumber, Big City Pickles, Red onion, and capers
Long Island $105

NY Dozen®, 1lb Traditional Tuna Salad, 1lb Traditional Chicken Salad, 1lb Sliced Turkey, Tomatoes, Baby Greens, Red Onion, Big City Pickles and Gotham Finest Cole Slaw
Brighton Beach $139

NY Dozen®, 1lb Lox, 8oz Hot Smoked Salmon, 8oz Smoked Whitefish Salad, 2- 8oz Spreads, Baby Greens, Red Onion, Tomatoes, Cucumber, Big City Pickles
Williamsburg $120

NY Dozen®, 1lb Smoked Heritage Ham, 1lb Pastrami, 1lb Corned Beef, 8oz Deli Coleslaw, (2) 4oz Gotham Deli Mustard, Big City Pickles
Big City Fruit Platter $45

Pineapple, grapes, blueberries, cantaloupe

Per Pound

Lox by the 1/2 Pound $18.75

with capers and red onion ($34.75 per pound)
Hot Smoked Salmon $18
Pastrami by the Pound $20.50

with NY Strong Mustard

New York Delicatessen Salads

Traditional Tuna Salad $5.75

8oz container
Gotham Chicken Salad $5.75

8oz container
Gotham Smoked Whitefish Salad $10.50

8oz container
Port Washington Salmon Salad $8
New York Deli Coleslaw $3.25

8oz container
Gotham Pickles $6.50

Quart
Gotham Bowtie Pesto Salad $4.75

8oz container

Ready to order?

Order online: pick your platters, choose your date and time, and pay ahead in a couple of minutes. Orders may be scheduled up to 90 days in advance.

Order Madison catering online Contact us

Questions first? Email madison@gothambagels.com or call (608) 467-7642.

Madison catering FAQ

Where does Gotham deliver catering in Madison?

Delivery is $9 within the City of Madison and $15 to Middleton or Sun Prairie. Anywhere else, call or email us. Pickup is at the shop, 112 E Mifflin St., a block off Capitol Square.

How far ahead can I schedule catering in Madison?

Online ordering takes orders up to 90 days ahead. A dozen or two and a platter can be delivered an hour after you order; for big orders (5 dozen bagels or 30 sandwiches and up), place your online order at least a day ahead so we can bake for you.

How many people does a Madison platter serve?

Every Madison platter comes with a dozen (13) bagels and serves 13, with baby greens, tomato, red onion, Big City pickles and coleslaw. Plan on one bagel per person and three 8 oz containers of cream cheese per dozen. JBC coffee service serves 12. The catering estimator does the math for your headcount.

More answers (changing an order, lox and cream cheese amounts, tableware, shipping, vegan and allergen notes) are in the full Madison catering FAQ.